When shopping for a mortgage, auto loan, personal loan, or student loan refinance, comparing offers is the single highest-ROI activity you can do. A difference of just 0.5% in interest rate on a $300,000 mortgage saves over $30,000 in total interest over 30 years. Yet most borrowers accept the first offer they receive.
The key to smart loan shopping is knowing what to compare and understanding that the lowest interest rate is not always the best deal.
Interest Rate vs APR: Know the Difference
The interest rate and APR (Annual Percentage Rate) are related but different:
- Interest rate: The base cost of borrowing, expressed as a percentage. This determines your monthly principal and interest payment.
- APR: The total cost of borrowing including the interest rate plus fees (origination fees, points, closing costs) spread over the loan term. APR is always equal to or higher than the interest rate.
- Why it matters: Loan A might offer 6.5% interest with $5,000 in fees (6.8% APR), while Loan B offers 6.75% interest with $1,000 in fees (6.85% APR). Despite the higher rate, Loan B may cost less if you sell or refinance within a few years.
The Five Key Factors to Compare
When evaluating loan offers side by side, focus on these five metrics:
- Monthly payment: Must fit your budget comfortably. Use the 28/36 rule for mortgages — housing costs under 28% of gross income, total debt under 36%.
- Total interest paid: The true cost of the loan over its full term. A lower monthly payment with a longer term often costs far more in total interest.
- Total cost (principal + interest + fees): The all-in price you pay. This is the ultimate comparison metric if you plan to keep the loan to term.
- Loan term: Shorter terms have higher monthly payments but dramatically lower total interest. Compare both 15-year and 30-year mortgage options.
- Fees and closing costs: Origination fees (0.5–1% of loan), application fees, appraisal fees, and points. Some lenders offer "no-fee" loans with slightly higher rates.
How Many Lenders Should You Compare?
Research consistently shows that comparing 3–5 lenders yields the best results. A 2024 Freddie Mac study found that borrowers who obtained five mortgage quotes saved an average of $3,000 over the loan's life compared to those who only got one quote.
Multiple loan applications within a 14–45 day window (depending on the scoring model) are treated as a single hard inquiry on your credit report. This means you can rate-shop aggressively without damaging your credit score.
- Banks: Traditional lenders with established processes. Rates are competitive but not always the lowest.
- Credit unions: Often offer the best rates, especially for auto loans and personal loans. Membership may be required.
- Online lenders: Quick pre-approval and competitive rates. Less personal service but often lower overhead translates to lower costs.
- Mortgage brokers: Shop multiple lenders on your behalf. Useful for complex situations but charge a fee (0.5–2.75% of loan).
Fixed vs Variable Rate Loans
This choice significantly affects your total cost:
- Fixed rate: Your rate and payment never change. Best when rates are relatively low or when you value predictability. In 2026 with rates at 6.5–7%, locking in a fixed rate protects you if rates rise further.
- Variable/adjustable rate: Starts lower than fixed but can increase over time. Best for short-term loans or when you plan to refinance or sell before the rate adjusts. Risk: rates could rise significantly.
When to Refinance an Existing Loan
Refinancing replaces your current loan with a new one at better terms. It makes sense when:
- You can lower your rate by 0.75–1%+ : This is the traditional threshold where refinancing costs are recouped within 1–2 years.
- Your credit score has improved significantly: A jump from 650 to 750 can drop your rate by 1–2 percentage points.
- You want to change the term: Refinancing a 30-year mortgage into a 15-year accelerates payoff and reduces total interest.
- You need to lower payments: Extending the term reduces monthly payments, though total interest increases. Only do this if cash flow is genuinely tight.
Try the Loan Comparison Calculator
Put this knowledge into action with our free calculator. Get instant, personalized results.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does comparing loans hurt my credit score?
No, if you do it within a short window. Credit scoring models (FICO and VantageScore) recognize rate shopping and treat multiple loan inquiries within a 14–45 day window as a single inquiry. This applies to mortgages, auto loans, and student loans. Shop aggressively within this window without worry.
Should I choose the loan with the lowest monthly payment?
Not necessarily. The lowest monthly payment often comes with the longest term and highest total interest cost. A $200,000 loan at 7% costs $1,331/month over 30 years ($279,000 total interest) but $1,798/month over 15 years ($123,000 total interest). The 15-year saves $156,000 despite a higher payment. Choose based on total cost, not just monthly payment.
What are discount points and should I buy them?
A discount point costs 1% of the loan amount and typically reduces your rate by 0.25%. On a $300,000 mortgage, one point costs $3,000 and might lower your rate from 7% to 6.75%, saving about $60/month. You break even in roughly 50 months (4.2 years). Buy points only if you plan to keep the loan longer than the breakeven period.
How do I compare a 15-year vs 30-year mortgage?
Our Loan Comparison Calculator makes this easy. Enter both scenarios and compare monthly payments, total interest, and total cost side by side. A 15-year mortgage typically has a rate 0.5–0.75% lower than a 30-year, a higher monthly payment (about 40–50% more), but saves 50–60% on total interest. Choose 15 years if the higher payment is comfortably within your budget.